Top Rated Product
Product Reviews
This product is no longer available. Continue shopping at Home Decorators Collection.
Average Customer Rating:
(32 Reviews) 28
Rating Snapshot (32 reviews)
5 stars
23
4 stars
4
3 stars
2
2 stars
3
1 star
0
27 of 32(84%)reviewers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for
Review 1 for
Overall:
Very Difficult
Easy
JoinLA
Nice looking but feet fall off.
Date:May 28, 2013
"The stool is great and easy to clean. The problem is that the 'feet' - the levels that keep the legs level to the floor fall off easily. We have lost two and Home Decorator's do not offer replacements or give any manufacturing info. I have looked in every Home Improvement store and there is no replacement. You have to order a whole new stool."
Share this Review:
Review 2 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Jack2
Location:Oregon
I have owned this product for:a month
Great addition
Date:May 27, 2013
"Beautiful swivel stools for our outdoor cooking/dining area. We also purchased the Sandra bar stools to use with these and they all look great."
Share this Review:
Review 3 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Very Difficult
Easy
Tweety18
Location:Sarasota, FL
Age:60-69
Gender:female
I have owned this product for:a week
Fabulous purchase
Date:September 21, 2012
"The stools are sleek, clean, and make a great look in our kitchen/family room! Love them and many have commented on how they look and are comfortable."
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review:
Review 4 for
Overall:
Appearance:
4
out of
5
Workmanship:
4
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Very Difficult
Easy
KJoM
Location:Virginia
Age:40-49
Gender:female
I have owned this product for:a week
Date:July 10, 2012
"This bar stool is exactly as it looks. It is light weight and easy to slide under the bar. It also has very nice pads on the legs to keep it from scatching wood floors. I ordered 2 and the swivel is a little stiff on one of the chairs but it still works."
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review:
Review 5 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
jimbob52
Location:Maryland
Age:60-69
Gender:male
I have owned this product for:a week
excellent product
Date:June 30, 2012
"The bar stools arrived quickly and in excellent condition. The workmanship is above average, the finish is exactly as pictured . . . better than expected for the price. A great value!"
Share this Review:
Review 6 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Cress
Location:Jersey shore
Age:60-69
Gender:female
I have owned this product for:a week
Better than Expected
Date:June 17, 2012
"Just unpacked our new Melanie Bar Stools. They look great! We are very happy with them, Good quality for a very reasonable price."
Share this Review:
Review 7 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Kitz
Love these bar stools !
Date:May 8, 2012
"Love the Melanie bar stools ! They look awesome in my kitchen ! Shipped quickly and arrived packaged well."
Share this Review:
Review 8 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Very Difficult
Easy
JackRabbit
Solid Aluminum Bar Stool
Date:May 8, 2012
"High quality, assembled already out of the box. Great deal and nice swivel action. Excellent Value"
Share this Review:
Review 9 for
Overall:
Very Difficult
Easy
ArizonaEntertainer
Location:Scottsdale, AZ
Age:30-39
I have owned this product for:more than a year
Great Stools for outdoors!
Date:March 4, 2012
"I really like these stools. I've purchased 6 of them over the years. They hold up to rain and dust storms really well and do no heat up too much in the hot sun. Easy to clean as well!"
Share this Review:
Review 10 for
Overall:
Appearance:
2
out of
5
Workmanship:
3
out of
5
Value:
2
out of
5
somewhatpicky
Finish Not As Expected
Date:January 19, 2012
"While the bar stool seems sturdy and arrived in good condition, I was disappointed in the finish. It is represented to be Brushed Aluminum but in my opinion looks more like silver spray paint. If that works for you, it would be suitable for a patio but I don't think it looks like an indoor piece. I would return it except for the hassle."
Share this Review:
Review 11 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Very Difficult
Easy
nanasb0ys
Location:lake stevens, washington
Age:50-59
Gender:female
I have owned this product for:a week
Date:January 17, 2012
"I had ordered the wrong size of stools. After talking to many people Marlin was very helpfull in making the return possiable so that I could reorder the right size. I am so happy and impressed that I will definatley be doing much more shopping. I love the stools and also the customer service that Marlin gave. thank you Marlin!!!"
Share this Review:
Review 12 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
4
out of
5
Very Difficult
Easy
Smileyface21047
Nice!
Date:December 28, 2011
"Came assembled and looks fabulous. A tad overpriced, but with coupons, totally worth it."
Share this Review:
Review 13 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Robinson1896
LOVE THE BARSTOOLS!
Date:December 22, 2011
Reviewer Images
(click to see full-size image)
"We love the aluminum barstools! We ordered 4 of the swivel barstools to accommodate a bar-height table made by my husband. They were timely delivered and the barstools are exactly what was presented in the product description. They are lightweight and comfortable. The finish is good, and I would definitely order them again!"
Share this Review:
Review 14 for
Overall:
Appearance:
3
out of
5
Workmanship:
3
out of
5
Value:
2
out of
5
MissFidget
Location:Delray Beach, Florida
Age:60-69
Gender:female
I have owned this product for:a week
Functional But Just OK
Date:December 2, 2011
"These are just O.K. I expected more for the price, but I guess they will serve the purpose."
Share this Review:
Review 15 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Very Difficult
Easy
tercerowines
Location:Los Olivos, CA
Age:40-49
Gender:male
I have owned this product for:about 6 months
Great Swivel Bar Stool
Date:October 6, 2011
"I purchased these for my small tasting room in the Santa Ynez Valley and they are perfect! Great style, great size, great price . . . . what else could you ask for?!?!?"
Share this Review:
Review 16 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Very Difficult
Easy
jennajo
Location:Southwest Georgia
Age:30-39
I have owned this product for:a month
outstanding all-around bar stool
Date:September 23, 2011
"Rarely have I been more pleased with an online purchase! This outstanding barstool's sleek, smooth, shiny appearance meshes with a wide variety of home decor. We have "coastal cottage" feel in our house, and these stools blend in beautifully. Their smooth, even swivel mechanism infinitely add to their appeal by giving kids a fun way to wiggle at mealtime and by allowing conversation to flow from "eating area" backwards to "living area" in our new open floor plan. awesome!! and we're very very picky people!! great value as well!! looked elsewhere for months and couldn't find its equal!! yahe!"
Share this Review:
Review 17 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
DEcustomer
Location:Delaware
I have owned this product for:a month
Perfect choice!
Date:September 22, 2011
"I have two of these stools in two different sizes. They look great and are exactly what I wanted. They work perfectly with historic-type decor -- my house was built in 1918 and I use one in my kitchen that was recently renovated to look like a butler's pantry from that period. But they would also work well with contemporary decor. Thanks!"
Share this Review:
Review 18 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
LexiLilac
Location:Philadelphia suburbs
Age:60-69
Gender:female
I have owned this product for:a month
Love these stools!
Date:September 20, 2011
"We chose the Melanie stools for our new home; first time we've ever had such a counter & had to select stools. Wanted them to look smart, clean and to function perfectly. They do all that and more. They are subtle but beautifully designed. Very sturdy and yet sit "quietly" under the counter. They fit into our contemporary decor but could be used with almost any style. A hit with us, for sure."
Share this Review:
Review 19 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Very Difficult
Easy
lkf222
Quality, Beautiful, Affordable stools
Date:June 17, 2011
"These stools look exactly as shown in the catalog and online. They are very lightweight, require no assembly, swivel nicely, are well-made, and look beautiful."
1 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review:
Review 20 for
Overall:
Appearance:
5
out of
5
Workmanship:
5
out of
5
Value:
3
out of
5
RPSHOP
Location:Bradenton, FL
Age:50-59
Gender:female
I have owned this product for:a month
Sleek and servicable
Date:December 31, 2010
"This bar stool is perfect for my outside lanai's summer kitchen. It's light, impervious to weather, won't fade, and will last for years to come. I couldn't be happier! I also own the counter height Melanie Stool that I use in an inside kitchen work area. Both tuck nicely under overhang counters. Most importantly, they are strong."
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review: